Big Tech must not be left alone with artificial intelligence

Aleksander Mądry joins Google CEO Eric Schmidt at Congress and urges lawmakers to ask rigorous questions about how AI tools are being used by corporations

Technology experts from the private sector and academia have called on the US government not to “abdicate” its responsibilities and leave the future path of artificial intelligence solely to Big Tech.

This call was issued by Aleksander Mądry, the Cadence Design Systems Professor of Computing at MIT and director of the MIT Center for Deployable Machine Learning, during a Congressional panel held last week. 

At the hearing - Advances in AI: Are We Ready for a Tech Revolution? - before the House Subcommittee on Cybersecurity, Information Technology, and Government Innovation, Mądry, a leading expert on explainability and AI, emphasised the importance of government regulation of corporate algorithms. 

Mądry argued that the government should ask questions about these algorithms' purpose and explainability to ensure that they align with society's goals. He expressed concern for the future of AI if the government fails to take action.

Other witnesses at the hearing included former Google CEO Eric Schmidt, IBM Vice President Scott Crowder, and Centre for AI and Digital Policy Senior Research Director Merve Hickok. In her opening remarks, Subcommittee Chair Rep. Nancy Mace referenced the book The Age of AI: And Our Human Future by Schmidt, Henry Kissinger, and Dan Huttenlocher, and a related op-ed in The Wall Street Journal that discussed ChatGPT. 

Mace also revealed that her formal opening remarks had been entirely written by ChatGPT.

AI has moved beyond science fiction

In his prepared remarks, Mądry raised three main points. He noted that AI has moved beyond science fiction and is now in the world, posing benefits and risks. He also expressed concern about the potential for AI to undermine human analytical skills by causing people to unquestioningly believe what AI produces. 

Mądry warned against regulating AI as if it were human and emphasised the importance of addressing problems resulting from the AI supply chain.

Mądry's concerns about the AI supply chain centred on the fact that AI systems are built on top of each other, with general systems like ChatGPT at the base and task-specific AI systems layered on top. This layering raises policy concerns, as the entire AI system is subject to the vulnerabilities and biases of the large system at its base. 

The interaction of AI systems is not well understood from a technical standpoint, making it difficult to predict or explain their results. Mądry also pointed out the difficulty of assigning legal liability when problems arise from the mix of AI tools.

Mądry concluded that AI technology is not well-suited for deployment through complex supply chains, even though this is precisely how it is deployed.

“We are at an inflection point in terms of what future AI will bring,” says Madry. “Seizing this opportunity means discussing the role of AI, what exactly we want it to do for us, and how to ensure it benefits us all. This will be a difficult conversation, but we do need to have it, and have it now.”

You can watch a video of the proceedings below, including testimonies from Eric Schmidt, Scott Crowder and  Merve Hickok.


Featured Articles

IBM and Tech Mahindra Seek to Power Up Gen AI Adoption

Both tech giants are partnering to harness the power of IBM's watsonx to help enterprises accelerate Gen AI adoption and offer new governance capabilities

NASA's First Chief AI Officer Shows AI's Value Cross Sector

NASA's appointing of inaugural CAIO David Salvagnini marks a significant stride towards AI integration across various sectors

OpenAI: A Look at the AI Trailblazer’s Leadership Landscape

We take a look at the heads leading the world's most famous AI startup following the news Co-founder and Chief Scientist Ilya Sutskever's will depart

Who Are Microsoft's LLM Contemporaries?

Machine Learning

Beyond the Hype: Unlocking Real Business Value With Gen AI

AI Strategy

OpenAI Poised to Announce Google Search Competitor

AI Applications